sds comments
Abortion Ethics: When Might Makes Right

adamquinn:

sds:

“Suppose, in the encounter between doctor and child [in an abortion], the child won half of the time, and killed the doctor in self-defense—something he would have every right to do. Very few doctors would perform abortions. They perform them now only because of their absolute power over a small, fragile, helpless victim.”

—Stephen D. Schwarz, The Moral Question of Abortion (Chicago: Loyola University Press, 1990), 143.

HT: Frank Beckwith, Defending Life, p. 228

(via Justin Taylor)

as a general rule, when you try to talk about abortion ethics, you should quote Peter Singer (or you know, any real ethicist) and not someone who sounds like they’re designing a picket sign for the fallacy rally

Good answer. That really engaged the discussion and convinced me.

  1. nerdfighterly reblogged this from love-and-radiation
  2. thedisgruntledgradstudent reblogged this from sinope
  3. sinope reblogged this from inothernews
  4. jmzmadx reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  5. apoplecticskeptic reblogged this from sds
  6. adamquinn reblogged this from sds and added:
    I just read all of the tagged posts. Some of the them I do like and some I do agree with, such as the commentary on the...
  7. putmybluesaway reblogged this from bthny
  8. sds reblogged this from adamquinn and added:
    You haven’t followed me for long, so I will excuse your ignorance of my willingness to discuss this issue publicly and...
  9. bthny reblogged this from muppetpants and added:
    haven’t been following this particular debate (and thank god, or I’d have probably leaked brains from my ears), and I’m...
  10. adamquinn reblogged this from sdscomments and added:
    I just think you don’t want to respond to my points publicly because you don’t have a decent response. I’m not trying to...
  11. sdscomments reblogged this from adamquinn
  12. sds reblogged this from muppetpants and added:
    Avoiding debating...Science has revealed much about pregnancy and human body in
  13. saitamanodoruji reblogged this from inothernews
  14. adamquinn reblogged this from sds and added:
    Besides highlighting that I accidentally repeated myself, you aren’t portraying anything wrong with my argument....
  15. sds reblogged this from adamquinn and added:
    his post, I’ll...more radical ones...let them speak for...
  16. adamquinn reblogged this from randyhaddock and added:
    “point” in another post. Learn...difference between ethics
  17. awfulopinions reblogged this from sds
blog comments powered by Disqus